[2020] NZIACDT 52 - TBE v Proudman (4 December 2020) [pdf, 202 KB]
...overall, is the penalty which is fair, reasonable and proportionate in the circumstances. DISCUSSION [27] Ms Proudman’s initial mistake was one of interpretation of the immigration instructions. While it could not be described as minor or simple human error, as the Tribunal pointed out in the substantive decision, Ms Proudman’s subsequent conduct has significantly exacerbated her wrongdoing.8 She concealed Immigration New Zealand’s decision from her client, falsely claimin...