Search Results

1. Collier - Torere Reserves Trust (2020) 241 Waiariki MB 13 (241 WAR 13) [pdf, 261 KB]

   ...prohibit the distribution of money collected for rent, purchase, royalties, etc. of the alienation of land, or of compensation payable in respect of other revenue derived from the land, affected by any order to which an application under s 45 or an appeal under Part 2 relates. [30] The established principles for granting a permanent injunction have been addressed by the Māori Appellate Court in Taueki v Horowhenua Sailing Club - Horowhenua 11 (Lake) Block as follows:6 [15] In...

2. [2020] NZEmpC 172 New Zealand Technology Group Hawkes Bay Ltd v Flashoff [pdf, 340 KB]

   ...freezing order could be made, the Court had to be satisfied that the applicant had a “good arguable case on an accrued or prospective cause of action” against the respondent.4 The Court was satisfied to the necessary standard. [24] The Court of Appeal has confirmed that a good arguable case is established if the allegations in the proposed claim are capable of tenable argument and are supported by sufficient evidence, bearing in mind the early stage at which the application is...

3. Pritchard v Toa-Wairere - Rangitatau Waitotara 3C2B2 3C2B3 (2021) 432 Aotea MB 112 (432 AOT 112) [pdf, 250 KB]

   ...concerning the use of the land and related activities were also again raised, and I pointed out that those matters and the issues set out in the farm consultant report had been canvassed in my earlier decision of 4 December 2019, which had not been appealed. At the conclusion of the hearing, I appointed the three nominated trustees for whom there were no objections and adjourned the application to chambers for a decision to issue in due course concerning the appointment of the remain...

4. Fenton - Rūrima Māori Reservation (2004) 102 Whakatāne 196 (102 WHK 196) [pdf, 851 KB]

   ...Waikato-Maniapoto ACMB 34. This case also concerned the election of trustees to a Maori reservation where the Lower Court, following a hui of beneficiaries, made orders removing trustees and appointing replacements. The Appellant, who was a beneficiary, appealed both orders. The Maori Appellate Court held that as the trustees who were removed had expressed a desire to resign, there was no issue with those orders. However, had any of the trustees disputed their resignations they would have...

5. Lake - Ngarara West B3B Trust (2003) 134 Aotea MB 20 (134 AOT 20) [pdf, 415 KB]

   ...[1988] 1 NZLR 197. The legal principles identified in the Maori Appellate Court decision in re Rata - Te Rongoroa A7 (1991) 13 Aotea Appellate MB 228 are relevant to the Termination Application, even though it deals with the previous legislation. That appeal concerned the refusal by the Lower Court to terminate Te Rongoroa Farm and Forest Trust in respect of Te Rongoroa A7 and to form a trust in respect of Te Rongoroa A7 and Part A8. In that case the Appellate Court had to consider wheth...

6. [2017] NZEnvC 038 Gravatt v Pierau [pdf, 547 KB]

   ...The Respondent Mr Pierau having been refused resource consent by Auckland Council to hold outdoor art, dance and music events, weddings and corporate functions on the southern part of his 31.8437 Ha rural site at 186 Atkins Road Tomarata, (under appeal lodged late last year but unlikely to be resolved until the second quarter of 2017), now proposed to hold a "Shipwrecked Festivaf' there during Waitangi weekend in early February, purportedly as a permitted temporary activity....

7. Philip Clarke (filed 6 June 2017) [pdf, 177 KB]

   BEFORE  THE  ENVIRONMENT  COURT       CHRISTCHURCH  REGISTRY     ENV-­‐2016-­‐CHC-­‐47     IN  THE  MATTER     of  an  appeal  under  section  120  of   the  Resource  Management  Act   1991   BETWEEN       BLUESKIN  ENERGY  LIMITED     Appellant                AND   DUNEDIN  CITY  COUNCIL       Respondent    ...

8. [2017] NZEmpC 81 Nelson Marlborough District Health Board v Henderson [pdf, 181 KB]

   ...cases where the Court had been prepared to use the regulation to award either indemnity costs or order costs “at or about the level of indemnity costs”. In Ben Nevis Forestry Ventures Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue 11 the Court of Appeal confirmed that the leading case on indemnity costs is Bradbury v Westpac Banking Corp. 12 In Bradbury the Court stated a non-exhaustive list of categories in which indemnity costs had been ordered as follows: 13 (a) the making o...

9. Craig - Wainui 2F4D (2005) 37 Kaikohe MB 19 (37 KH 19) [pdf, 687 KB]

   ...part of the land to daughter Bertha, with the Applicant retaining the balance, and (b) each to sell a part in order to build or develop the balance each retained. In support, the Applicant relies upon the Maori Appellate Court decision Re White (Appeal 1998/18) and the Court of Appeal decision Bruce & Ors v Edward & Ors [2002] CA 19/02. Applicant's counsel argues that, in determining effective management and utilisation of land, the Court must not only take an objective vi...

10. Legal Complaints Review Officer v Morrison [2018] NZLCDT 40 [pdf, 339 KB]

    ...the Act). 4. Mr Morrison is to refund to the New Zealand Law Society the costs of the Tribunal in full (pursuant to s 249 of the Act). 5. The existing orders for non-publication are to continue in force pending the outcome of Mr Morrison’s appeal to the High Court. 6. The order for suspension is not to come into force until the outcome of the appeal. DATED at AUCKLAND this 27th day of November 2018 BJ Kendall Chairperson...